Skip to content

Appendix G: PostgreSQL vs Azure SQL Cost Analysis

Note

The following analysis is based on Microsoft's official published pricing using the Azure price calculator. It is based on primary resources being provisioned in Azure's Australia Southeast (Melbourne) zone, with failover replicas in Azure's Australia East (Sydney) zone. All costs are based on prices published on 26 May 2025 with Azure's currency exchange rate of 1 USD = 1.56 AUD. All prices are in AUD.

🎯 Overview

📊 Metric 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 💡 Advantage
Monthly Total A$6,276.96 A$2,581.75 59% savings
Annual Total A$75,323.52 A$30,981.00 A$44,342.52 savings
3-Year Total A$225,970.56 A$92,943.00 A$133,028 savings

💸 Detailed Cost Analysis

📅 Monthly Cost Breakdown

🏗️ Environment 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 💰 Monthly Savings 📈 Savings %
DEV/UAT/TRN A$1,153.65 A$676.08 A$477.57 41%
PROD A$4,967.60 A$1,749.97 A$3,217.63 65%
🎯 Total Monthly A$6,276.96 A$2,581.75 A$3,695.21 59%

🎯 3-Year Cost Projection

💰 Financial Metric 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 💡 PostgreSQL Advantage
3-Year Total A$225,970.65 A$92,943.00 A$133,027.65 savings
Monthly Average A$6,276.96 A$2,581.75 59% cost reduction

🛠️ Feature Capability Comparison

🔧 Specification 🔵 Azure SQL (Premium) 🟢 PostgreSQL (E8ads v5) 📊 Performance Analysis
vCore Count 8 vCores 8 vCores ✅ Equivalent compute
Memory Configuration Premium memory optimised 64 GiB dedicated 🟰 Comparable for spatial workloads
Service Tier Hyperscale Memory Optimised 🟰 Both suitable for large datasets
Spatial Capability Basic spatial support PostGIS full capabilities 🟢 PostgreSQL superior

💾 Storage and Backup Comparison

PROD Storage Comparison

💾 Component 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 📊 Analysis
Primary Storage 500GB ZRS 500GB Premium SSD v2 🟰 Comparable capacity
High Availability 1 HA Replica Zone Redundant HA 🟰 Equivalent availability
Backup Storage 1,500GB RA-ZRS 1,500GB GRS 🟰 Comparable redundancy
Long-term Retention 36 months 36 months 🟰 Comparable retention
I/O Performance Hyperscale optimised Premium SSD v2 🟰 Both high-performance

DEV/UAT/TRN Storage Comparison

💾 Component 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 📊 Analysis
Primary Storage 50GB LRS 50GB Premium SSD v2 🟢 PostgreSQL superior I/O
Backup Strategy Standby Replica LRS Backup 🔵 Real-time replica
Performance Type Standard General Purpose Premium SSD v2 🟢 PostgreSQL higher IOPS

High Availability and Disaster Recovery

🛡️ Feature 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 💰 Cost Impact
Zone Redundancy ZRS (PROD only) Built-in HA 🟢 Included in PostgreSQL cost
Standby Replicas 1 HA Replica (PROD) Zone Redundant HA 🟰 Comparable protection
Backup Retention 36-month LTR (PROD) 36-month LTR (PROD) 🟰 Equivalent retention
Recovery Options Point-in-time restore Point-in-time restore 🟰 Comparable DR
Availability SLA 99.99% (ZRS) 99.99% (Zone Redundant) 🟰 Equivalent uptime

Performance Comparison

Performance Aspect 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 🏆 Advantage
Spatial Functions Basic spatial support PostGIS full capabilities 🟢 PostgreSQL superior
Memory Optimisation Premium memory series E-series memory optimised 🟰 Comparable
I/O Performance Hyperscale architecture Premium SSD v2 🟰 Both suitable for ArcGIS
Scalability Up to 100TB storage Up to 64TB storage 🔵 SQL better for massive scale

Management and Integration

🛠️ Feature 🔵 Azure SQL 🟢 PostgreSQL 📊 Consideration
ArcGIS Integration Enterprise Geodatabase PostGIS/Enterprise GDB 🟢 PostgreSQL native spatial advantage
Monitoring Azure Monitor Azure Monitor 🟰 Comparable monitoring
Maintenance Fully managed Fully managed 🟰 Equivalent management overhead
Support Standard tier Standard tier 🟰 Equivalent support levels
Developer Tools Azure ecosystem Azure ecosystem + Postgres extensions 🟢 PostgreSQL broader compatibility

🔧 Configuration Specifications

🔵 Azure SQL Database Configuration

⚙️ DEV/UAT/TRN Environment Specifications

🏷️ Component 📋 Configuration 💰 Cost Impact
Computing Tier Provisioned Standard billing
Hardware Series Standard-series Gen 5 Intel-based processors
vCore Count 4 vCore A$288.41/vCore/month
Service Tier General Purpose Basic redundancy
Disaster Recovery Standby Replica Included in cost
Zone Redundancy Locally Redundant Standard availability
Reserved Capacity 3-year reservation 60% discount applied
Storage Capacity 50GB LRS backup storage
Monthly Cost A$1,153.65 41% higher than PostgreSQL

🎯 PROD Environment Specifications

🏷️ Component 📋 Configuration 💰 Cost Impact
Computing Tier Provisioned Premium billing
Hardware Series Premium memory optimised High-performance processors
vCore Count 8 vCore A$620.95/vCore/month
Service Tier Hyperscale Unlimited scale capability
Zone Redundancy Zone Redundant Storage Enterprise availability
High Availability 1 HA Replica Automatic failover
Reserved Capacity 3-year reservation Maximum discount applied
Storage Capacity 500GB + 1,500GB backup RA-ZRS redundancy
Long-term Retention 36-month backup retention Extended compliance
Support Tier Standard support Professional assistance
Monthly Cost A$4,967.60 65% higher than PostgreSQL

🟢 PostgreSQL Flexible Server Configuration

⚙️ DEV/UAT/TRN Environment Specifications

🏷️ Component 📋 Configuration 💰 Cost Impact
Deployment Model Flexible Server Modern architecture
Performance Tier General Purpose Balanced compute
Instance Series Dadsv5 Series AMD-based processors
vCore Count D4ads v5, 4 vCore A$169.02/vCore/month
Reserved Capacity 3-year reservation Maximum discount applied
Storage Type Premium SSD v2 High-performance I/O
Storage Capacity 50GB Scalable storage
Backup Strategy LRS, 0GB additional Standard retention
Monthly Cost A$676.08 41% lower than Azure SQL

🎯 PROD Environment Specifications

🏷️ Component 📋 Configuration 💰 Cost Impact
Deployment Model Flexible Server Enterprise-ready
Performance Tier Memory Optimised Spatial workload optimised
Instance Series Eadsv5 Series High-memory AMD processors
vCore Count E8ads v5, 8 vCore A$218.75/vCore/month
Reserved Capacity 3-year reservation Maximum discount applied
Storage Type Premium SSD v2 Ultra-high performance
Storage Capacity 500GB + 1,500GB backup Enterprise capacity
High Availability Zone Redundant HA Automatic failover
Backup Strategy GRS redundancy Geographic protection
Support Tier Standard support Professional assistance
Monthly Cost A$1,749.97 65% lower than Azure SQL

✅ Conclusion

PostgreSQL configuration delivers:

  • Equivalent compute capacity with 4 vCore (DEV/UAT/TRN) and 8 vCore (PROD) configurations
  • Suitable memory optimisation for spatial workloads
  • Equivalent availability through zone redundant high availability
  • Superior spatial functionality via PostGIS integration with ArcGIS Enterprise
  • Significant cost advantages projected saving of $133,028 over 3 years